This Sunday's readings are hard. There is no way around it. They are about greed and wealth. And as a society we don't do well with talking honestly about greed and wealth. We make excuses for ourselves, for our friends, for our economics. I know I do. All of the time. I am sure we can all think of ways in which we build bigger barns for ourselves. It shouldn't be hard or take more than a minute.
There is a great
discussion going over at
dotCommonweal started by
Fr. Joe Komonchak with wonderful quotes from the Church Fathers railing against greed. There is an especially good one from my favorite, John Chrysostom. Harsh words:
Tell me, then, what is the source of your wealth? From whom did you receive it, and from whom the one who transmitted it to you? “From his father and his grandfather.” But can you go back through the many generations and show the acquisition just? It cannot be. The root and origin of it must have been injustice. Why? Because God in the beginning did not make one man rich and another poor. Nor did he later show one treasures of gold and deny the other the right of to search for it. He left the earth free to all alike. Why then, if it is common, do you have so many acres of land, while your neighbor has no portion of it?
Over at
SLU's Center for Liturgy there are some great reflections and guides to the readings for those who are looking for multiple perspectives from which to tackle these thorny issues.
But for me, this week, the key is the first conversation in the
Gospel.
Someone in the crowd said to Jesus,
“Teacher, tell my brother to share the inheritance with me.”
He replied to him,
“Friend, who appointed me as your judge and arbitrator?”
Then he said to the crowd,
“Take care to guard against all greed,
for though one may be rich,
one’s life does not consist of possessions.”
Often we hear that the answer is for the those who have to share with those don't. Or for a systematic restructuring of resources, or for more tithing, or more whatever so that there is more justice. But in this conversation Jesus' critique is so much more damning than that, and so much more universal. Jesus is, in effect, telling the brother to not want the inheritance. He does not believe that sharing is the answer, the answer is not wanting in the first place.
Now does this mean that Jesus turns a blind eye to those in need. Not at all. Jesus believes that all should have what they need and that we must help those in need. But he tells everyone here, don't want. That is much harder. And that applies to all of us, not just the rich.